The UK government has been ordered to confirm that it issued a secret Apple backdoor order demanding access to encrypted customer information. The Investigatory Powers Tribunal, the independent court where citizens can challenge government surveillance, handed down the ruling on Thursday. It rejected the Home Office’s argument that confirming the order would damage national security.
It is a rare setback for a government that wanted the whole matter kept a state secret.
What the tribunal decided
The Home Office sought to keep even the existence of the order confidential. The tribunal disagreed and said the government must confirm it. Details of what the order contains are a separate question: a final hearing on which specifics can be released is expected next year.
The Home Office hasn’t yet confirmed the notice exists. A spokesperson did not respond to a request for comment.
The challenge was brought by the rights group Liberty International on behalf of two individuals. Liberty says it’s the first known time the government has been compelled to confirm a secret technical order.
How the dispute began
A year ago, the UK government reportedly demanded that Apple build a backdoor so authorities could reach customer data anywhere in the world. The demand came as a “technical capabilities notice,” which is issued under strict non-disclosure rules. Details leaked to the media anyway.
The leak drew criticism from White House officials and US lawmakers. They argued that the order would put Americans’ privacy at risk, since a way into one set of encrypted accounts is difficult to confine to citizens of one country.
What Apple did
Apple, based in California, refused the order. It also blocked UK users from switching on Advanced Data Protection, its encryption feature for iCloud, instead of complying.
The UK later narrowed the order so it covered data stored in Apple’s encrypted cloud by British nationals. Apple challenged that second order too.
Until this ruling, Apple was legally barred from discussing the notice, even after the details leaked. The company told reporters it welcomes the decision to make public that the Home Office issued a technical capability notice. It has said before that it has “never built a backdoor or master key” to any of its products or services and “never will.”
What a technical capability notice is
A technical capability notice is an order the government can serve on a company, requiring it to maintain the ability to give authorities access to data. It comes with strict non-disclosure rules, so a recipient normally can’t confirm that it exists, let alone argue its case in public. That secrecy is why the Apple case, once details leaked, became a flashpoint for privacy advocates on both sides of the Atlantic.
Why the ruling matters
Technical capability notices are designed to be secret. Companies that receive one usually can’t say so, and the public has no way to test whether the powers are being used proportionately. By forcing the government to acknowledge the notice, the tribunal has opened a small crack in that wall.
- The government can no longer treat the Apple order’s existence as a state secret.
- Apple can now speak about the notice, though it still hasn’t seen details released.
- UK users remain unable to turn on Advanced Data Protection for iCloud.
What happens next
The next step is the final hearing, expected next year, which will decide what specific information about the order can be published. The Home Office and the challengers are likely to disagree about how much can be shown, including how far the narrowed order reaches.
Apple’s position hasn’t changed since the first order: it won’t build a way in. Its choice to pull Advanced Data Protection from UK users rather than weaken it for everyone remains in place, which means people in Britain still have less protection on iCloud than customers elsewhere.
The outcome could shape how other technology companies respond if they receive similar notices. For now, the confirmed point is narrow but real: the order exists, and the government has to say so.
Source: TechCrunch