Lumentum CEO Michael Hurlston knows investors dislike the Lumentum Marvell deal. “It’s been a rough go,” he said in an interview on Thursday. His message to shareholders: bear with us.
The two companies agreed to a $115 billion all-stock combination earlier this month. Shares of both have fallen roughly 40% since the announcement.
How the deal came about
Hurlston says Lumentum had been looking for a chip company for months. “We felt like we needed semiconductor properties, so we were actually in the market,” he said. Marvell heard about the search and proposed combining instead.
The merger puts Lumentum’s optical technology together with Marvell’s chip businesses. Optical links are a key part of the data center buildout because they move data between high-powered GPUs and the networks beyond them. On paper, Hurlston says, the logic was clear: if Lumentum needed a semiconductor asset, Marvell is the best maker in this area.
Why investors are unhappy
Shareholders see two problems. Some at Lumentum argue the company sold too soon. Hurlston acknowledged the view: investors feel the company took some upside off the table and tied itself to a partner whose upside is less known.
There’s also worry about how much room the AI trade has left to run. Hurlston added that the two companies share about 80% of their shareholders by his math. Portfolio managers who hold one stock but not the other may be forced to sell, which adds pressure.
Can the deal still fall apart?
It could. The agreement includes a material adverse change clause. But Hurlston says the circumstances in which Lumentum can use it are very limited. “We’re going to have to see this thing through, unless shareholders vote no, or if we don’t get regulatory approval,” he said.
He expects the stock to recover once the companies share more through regulatory filings and meetings with analysts and portfolio managers.
The pitch to customers
Hurlston says hyperscalers care most about continuity of supply and time to market. Selling the optical and chip products as one finished system would let both companies deliver faster, because the products can ship to data centers together.
Regulatory review in the US and China
Both countries will examine the merger. Scrutiny in China is likely to be sharper following the Nvidia chip scandal, and Nvidia is both a shareholder and a major customer of Lumentum.
Hurlston and Marvell CEO Matt Murphy have each taken deals through China’s State Administration for Market Regulation before, so Hurlston says they know what to expect. His read is that Beijing wants its supply secured, and Lumentum is a critical supplier of transistors into the Chinese market.
The Nvidia CEO question
It has been reported that Murphy could be tapped as Nvidia’s CEO after Jensen Huang’s resignation. Hurlston said he didn’t know whether Murphy was considering the role or would accept it, but added, “I think he can do the job.”
He argued that Nvidia’s board will want a sitting CEO with a clean record, and said Murphy’s work at Marvell has been terrific.
What the stock drop means
A 40% fall in both stocks matters more than usual in an all-stock deal, because the value each side receives moves with the share prices. The headline figure of $115 billion was set at announcement, and the market has since marked both companies down sharply.
Hurlston’s argument is that the decline reflects uncertainty about the AI trade and about the new combined company, not a flaw in the strategy. Investors will judge that once more numbers are public.
What happens next
Shareholder votes and regulatory approvals in the US and China are the next hurdles for the Lumentum Marvell deal. Until those clear, expect the stocks to keep trading on AI sentiment and on how much detail the companies release in their filings. Hurlston’s bet is that more information will calm investors. If it doesn’t, the vote is where their frustration would show.
For now, the deal remains a $115 billion wager that customers want optics and silicon sold as a single system. The market hasn’t agreed yet.
Source: semafor.com