AI gig work now covers medical specialists. Scale AI’s Outlier platform lists pay of up to $180 an hour for American physicians who build complex cardiac cases, check AI-written reports and rank model answers. A comparable role in the Philippines, working in Tagalog, tops out at $7.50 an hour, and in Tanzania, working in Swahili, at $12.50.
Pay differs by a factor of 24. The platform’s grip over the worker doesn’t.
Cheap labor first, expert labor now
Data vendors originally sent labeling tasks wherever wages were lowest. They now court doctors, attorneys and doctorate holders to write training examples, score answers and verify results. A bigger credential can lift the listed rate, yet the platform still decides payment and conditions.
Venezuela offers the clearest picture of the low end. Rogelio used to teach computer science, until the economic collapse and the pandemic cost his family their income. His 13-year-old son realized a school laptop issued by the Chรกvez government could earn money by tagging photos of cars and roads on Hive and on Scale AI’s Remotasks. He earned 18 cents for a few hours. Rogelio joined and cleared just over $2 on day one.
Rates start high, then fall
At first it was worthwhile. A task nicknamed Beast Mode, tagging items inside private homes, paid more than any earlier job the family had held. In December 2020, with classes suspended and the whole household working, a single day yielded $20. They never made more. Beast Mode disappeared by early 2021, and their income dropped under Hive’s $5 weekly minimum for payouts.
Observers say many platforms follow this script: lure workers with good pay, then trim rates and shift attention elsewhere. Remotasks closed its hourly program in Venezuela in 2021 and entered Kenya that same year. By March 2024 it had stopped operating in Kenya, Nigeria and Pakistan. Scale AI cited enhanced security protocols and said it gave three weeks’ notice, then conceded that Kenyan workers never got the message because of operational errors. Workers interviewed at the time mostly said they were simply locked out.
Scholars use the word extractivism for arrangements that pull value out of places and people for gain elsewhere on the buyer’s terms. Venezuela’s crisis grew from an oil economy that built little else. An oil field can’t relocate, but a platform can route its next tasks to a different country.
What the contract allows
Outlier’s terms allow it to pause or delay payment while reviewing a worker’s tasks, and to keep some or all earned money if it decides there was a violation, in its sole determination. It can also shut an account at once, without warning, for any reason. Identical wording appeared in the Remotasks terms that Rogelio’s family accepted in 2021.
Better-paid workers meet the same cycle. Reporter Josh Dzieza spoke with over 30 laid-off lawyers, scientists and screenwriters now working on such platforms. Nearly all said expectations grew, time targets tightened and pay slid as a project aged. One designer labeled videos for Meta at $21 an hour until the project closed for scope changes. A few days later an identical job appeared under another name at $16.
People can quit, and some do. The ones who remain frequently have no alternative. A Venezuelan woman housebound by illness during Covid said the work was her only income.
Nobody takes responsibility
A 2024 session organized by Partnership on AI and Fairwork, a project that scores platform firms, brought AI companies and their outsourcing suppliers into one room. The AI firms argued the data workers weren’t their employees. The suppliers said the prices set by their clients dictated how they operated. All agreed wages should go up. When someone raised worker representation, silence followed, since no workers had been invited.
Legal pushback
In March 2023 a Kenyan court paused the firing of 260 Facebook content moderators, kept Meta from handing their work to a new contractor and barred Meta and its contractor Majorel from blacklisting them. Meta relocated the work to West Africa while the dispute continued.
U.S. litigation is growing. Complaints from Scale AI workers produced a settlement proposal that a San Francisco court has preliminarily approved, and the company denies any wrongdoing. Another class action claims Mercor wrongly classified over 30,000 lawyers, physicians and engineers as contractors while controlling their pay and work. OpenAI, Anthropic and Meta have been Mercor clients but aren’t defendants. That case continues.
What comes next
A cardiologist paid three figures an hour and a Venezuelan teacher paid dollars are in different places. Both can see rates move overnight, tasks vanish without notice and decisions made without them. The San Francisco settlement and the Mercor case are the ones to follow, because they could determine how platforms must classify and pay the people who train AI models.
Source: Rest of World